Topbar

ITWeb Lite - Take IT easy

LIMITED OFFER
Subscribe
to Brainstorm Magazine for R199.95 today and get 11 issues PLUS a FREE APC Biometric Password Manager (valued at over R450.00) absolutely FREE.
Click here.

back to the ITWeb home page Sales info
SEARCH 
BUSINESS
more in business...  

advertisement


Loading...
FINANCIAL
more in financial...  
COMPUTING
more in computing...  
INTERNET
more in internet...  
ENTERPRISE
more in enterprise...  
NETWORKING
more in networking...  
TELECOMS
more in telecoms...  
CHANNEL
more in channel...  

advertisement

Back to the Reviews Home Page 21 August 2002 
Utopia: paying the price
Minority Report deals with a society where murder has been eliminated. However, this comes at a price. The movie raises important questions about privacy and the nature of liberty. It offers an enjoyable, but overrated, movie experience.
Who wouldn't want to live in a society where a judicial system has been put in place that allows people to be arrested and convicted before they commit murder? Given our country's high crime rate, most South Africans would probably give anything to assure their place in this supposed utopia.

John Anderton (Tom Cruise) and Pre-Cog Agatha (Samantha Morton)
John Anderton (Tom Cruise) and Pre-Cog Agatha (Samantha Morton)
Directed by Steven Spielberg, Minority Report is based on the short story by science fiction writer Philip K Dick. It is set in Washington in 2054 and promises such a society.

The US Justice Department is to conduct a vote on whether to take its Pre-Crime unit national. This unit, led by John Anderton (Tom Cruise), uses three psychics, the Pre-Cogs, to provide it with images of murders that will be committed and the names of the future victims and murderers. Investigators then use this information to piece together where the murder will take place and arrest people before they get a chance to commit the crime.

Anderton, driven by the loss of his son, believes the system is perfect. Along with Lamar Burgess (Max von Sydow), the father of the Pre-Crime unit, he has become one of its biggest campaigners.

However, as the latest murder vision arrives, Anderton sees that he will murder a stranger within the next 36 hours. He flees and must uncover the truth behind the question he has spent the last six years in eliminating: Is it possible for the Pre-Cogs to be wrong?

 VITAL STATS

Opens: 30 August
Director: Steven Spielberg
Cast: Tom Cruise, Lois Smith, Samantha Morton, Peter Stormare, Max von Sydow
Classification: 16V
Running Time: 150 minutes

Based on a Philip K. Dick short story, Minority Report is about a cop in the future working in a division of the police department that arrests killers before they commit the crimes courtesy of some future viewing technology. Cruise's character has the tables turned on him when he is accused of a future crime and must find out what brought it about and stop it before it can happen.

In keeping with the subject matter, Spielberg's Washington of the future is a place where privacy does not exist. Thanks to optical recognition, people are bombarded with personalised advertisements wherever they go. Even the Pre-Cogs' ability to see future crimes raises the question of how much government organisations know about the individual.

Like so many other science fiction movies, Spielberg could easily have fallen into the trap of focusing on the special effects and scenery to the detriment of the plot. Luckily, this is not the case. The effects are well done and the Washington of 2054 has been accurately created in the context of the movie. This succeeds in drawing the viewer into the movie. The story focuses on how technology influences society and not on overwhelming the audience with dazzling effects.

The father of the Pre-Crime unit, Lamar Burgess (Max von Sydow)
The father of the Pre-Crime unit, Lamar Burgess (Max von Sydow)
Cruise's recent movies (Vanilla Sky, Eyes Wide Shut) have shown that he wants to be known for his depth of acting and not just as a pretty face. In Minority Report he is successful. He gives a believable, although at times melodramatic, performance of a man who is caught up in a struggle that has become bigger than him.

Samantha Morton also does well in a difficult role as the enigmatic Pre-Cog Agatha.

Unfortunately, Spielberg's need to tie up loose ends overshadows the complex nature of the story. The question of whether a person can be arrested for a crime he/she has not even committed is never adequately answered. A dichotomy is created between predetermination and the right of choice early in the film, but is never explored to a satisfying conclusion.

Anderton (Cruise) goes for a ride in Minority Report
Anderton (Cruise) goes for a ride in Minority Report
I cannot help but wonder what would have happened if an independent film studio had made this movie. Granted, the effects would probably not have been as good, but at least you would have a movie that succeeds in portraying the dark future of author Dick much in the same way as another Dick adaptation, Ridley Scott's Bladerunner.

Having said that, Minority Report is better than your run-of-the-mill Hollywood science fiction movie and is sure to rake in the money. The movie's slick delivery is its downfall though. It succeeds in raising important issues such as the nature of liberty and privacy, but then fails in its follow through.

More movie reviews:
Eight Legged Freaks
Lilo & Stitch
The New Guy
The Believer
Resident Evil

  MORE NEWS
  e-Skills Academy faces liquidation
  Neotel steps up a gear
  Vodacom takes 51% of Stortech
   MOST POPULAR
  MTN, Neotel boost national capacity
  Neotel network takes a knock
  Fifa careful on Satyam troubles

Quick Print
Send to a friend
Send to a cell phone
Personal Archive

Register | Learn more...
Latest Blogs:
TownBoy
TownBoy-“Mobile Mumbles - Part 2”(Weapons of Mobile Destruction
Bullfrog
I am bestowed by the ironies of my life.....
jelo
The OpenSource Hoohah
www.blogit.co.za
Give us feedback

ITWeb Events Calendar
2010
> Virtualisation & Cloud Computing
21-22 July | The Forum, Bryanston
This conference is designed for enterprise IT professionals who want to understand how to better manage the virtualised environment and also learn about the various categories of cloud computing and what the implications of moving to the cloud are for their business.
> MobileBiz
28-29 July |  Vodaworld, Midrand
Attend this conference and you will explore the potential of the mobile business platform for B2B and B2C applications, as well as the significant technical and managerial challenges.
> SMEXA
3-4 August | The Forum, Bryanston
SMEXA is the only forum of its kind in SA, bringing you the best ITSM trends and solutions information available, and providing an opportunity to evaluate the various solutions available, in a hands-on environment.

Send mail to the Author
Got an opinion or a comment on this article you'd like to share with Iwan Pienaar? Drop an e-mail to the author.
Tell us about this article
Well Worth Reading
Worth Reading
Waste of Time
to the top of this page

Copyright (c) 1996 - 2012 ITWeb Limited. All rights reserved.

Would you like to see your news here? Contact us for more details at itnews@itweb.co.za

Striata Rackspace Sophos BBG Technologies